Tuesday 10/28/2025
First thing to do today was to write something for the writers group. I’d stiffed them for 2 or 3 weeks running. The prompt was “title and first paragraph of a novel you’d like to write.” Thrashing around I was thinking about how SF is dead because of AI.
(Any future that a Millennial or Gen-Z reader can conceive, since 2024, has to have AI in it. But if you have credible AI, what’s left for your protagonists to do? Just ask the AI. Makes you appreciate Frank Herbert, when he wrote Dune in 1965 he foresaw this very problem. He made sure that his 10,000 year future would still be human-scale by having them remember a terrible war against the robots, and artificial intelligence being banned. So the desert Fremen can fight with swords in AD 11,000, and we can have a successful movie franchise.)
So I wrote a scene between a jaded SF writer and his agent where they discuss this problem.
Got in some reading and some guitar before 3pm when I had to attend an appreciation fund meeting, requested to do the same magic I had done before, capture the audio transcript and feed it through Claude to get a meeting summary. Speaking of AI. From there to the 11th floor to put the Stanford “Reimagining Democracy” webinar on the big TV. 6 people attended. Then down to dinner, Prue had arranged dinner for our friend Connie, with me, Peter, and Joanne.
After which it was time for the monthly sing-along in the lobby.
Waiting for the Butlerian Jihad(*)
Ryan took a long pull from his beer, placed the glass on the bar with precise care, took a deep breath, and pronounced, “No. It’s pointless.”
Ashley rotated her glass of ginger ale and for the fourth time, lifted the stem of the maraschino cherry and gently let it drop back. “Oh come on, your last two books sold; one was even optioned.”
“Yeah, optioned. Then nothing. You know why? Because the movie dudes see the same thing I do. Science fiction is dead. Killed stony dead by AI.” He pushed his beer glass around a little square pattern and sighed.
“You don’t use AI,” Ashley objected, “Nobody serious does. My staff watches for the slop, they turn an AI manuscript around so fast the postage has scorch marks.”
“Ashley, you don’t get it. It isn’t the writing, it’s the plots! Just by existing, AI has killed SF plots.” He took another long pull from his beer and paused. His agent just looked at him, waiting for him to go on.
“OK, here. First, you can’t read the old stuff any more. Pick any SF book from the last year. Set in the future, right? Except, where’s the AI? Your POV has a problem, why didn’t she ask GPT-19? Zip, no problem. Every conceivable future — any future we can conceive of now, any future that a millennial or Alpha reader can conceive of — has to have AI in it. Which any SF book published before 2024, including mine, does not.” He glared at his beer glass and burped. “It’s like nobody can read Robert Heinlein any more because, good as his shit was, his characters don’t have pocket phones or even computers for fuck’s sake. No, Ashley, to be believable, any SF story has to better AI than we have now. Which means, the characters can solve all their problems by just asking the AI, and you have no plot.” He burped again. “Excuse me.”
Ashley dunked the maraschino in the flat ginger ale again. “OK, wait, how about two AIs have some kind of conflict.”
“AIs as characters? Just shoot me now.”
“Well, no, the AIs are in some kind of contention, different thingies, what’s the word, alignments. And they aren’t the characters, they’re off-stage. The human characters are like, subverted, or co-opted. To do the AI’s dirty work.”
“Huh,” Ryan said, and mused a moment. “OK,… and then the characters catch on and realize they aren’t really enemies…?”
“Right, so they join forces…”
“Hah! And fall in love! But now the AIs are trying to wipe them both out!”
“Sounds good,” said Ashley. “Shoot me a 20-page treatment and I’ll shop it around.”
(*) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(franchise)#Butlerian_Jihad